Ever wondered whether the way family or caregivers behave with the patients leaves a lasting impact on the illness? Whether if its a physical and mental illness the attitude portrayed towards the patient plays a significant role in their relapse and recovery journey. The term Schizophrenia was first coined by Eugen Bleuler. Schizophrenia means split mind. Literally, the term translates to “split mind. It is one of the most complex, chronic and difficult-to-treat disorders. Specifically, schizophrenia presents with positive symptoms (hallucinations and delusions) and negative symptoms (apathy, anhedonia, and alogia).
The development and course of schizophrenia are chronic, and early onset can make it difficult for the patient and family members. Essentially, psychotic features characterise schizophrenia. More than two out of three people with psychosis do not receive adequate support and mental health care. It is not a common disorder. Individuals with schizophrenia die nine years earlier than the general population (Patel et al., 2014; World Health Organisation, 2026). This article aims to shed light on the role of expressed emotions and how they play an important role in the relapse of schizophrenia.
What is Expressed Emotion (EE)
Expressed emotion as its name suggests its meaning, it refers to the adverse family surroundings and the quality of the interaction among family members of those with psychotic disorders. It is the caregiver’s attitude towards the patient or the way they behave. Expressed Emotion has gained importance in clinical settings because it significantly impacts the relapse of psychotic disorders.
Studies have reported that Expressed Emotion is one of the major psychosocial stressors, and it has a direct relationship with the recurrence of the disorder. Research studies have proven that individuals with schizophrenia who are living with their family and have a negative attitude towards them are more likely to relapse. It is evident that the quality of relationship with family and caregivers determines the course, development, relapse and treatment outcome of the disorder(Amaresha et al., 2012).
Origins of Expressed Emotion
The concept of Expressed Emotion has its origin in the work of George Brown in his seminal work during the 1950s. George Brown joined the Medical Research Council Social Psychiatry (MRCSP) Unit of London in 1956. When he joined the unit, doctors were treating patients with schizophrenia with the antipsychotic drug chlorpromazine. This drug had gained wide popularity because it allowed many patients to leave the hospital.
However, soon after discharge, many patients relapsed and returned to the hospital. Because relapse occurred even though doctors had given them antipsychotic drugs, George Brown wanted to understand the underlying reason. To investigate, Brown and his colleagues studied 229 men whom the hospital had discharged from the ward, and clinicians had diagnosed 156 of them with schizophrenia.
The results were somewhat contradictory: patients who stayed with their family, spouse, or caregivers showed a higher risk of relapse, whereas those who stayed in lodging, hotels, or alone showed a lower risk. However, patients need family and close social connections in times of distress, although not all of them receive that care from their families. In some cases, families treat patients as a burden, which leads to stress and a higher risk of symptom relapse (Amerseha et al., 2012).
High and Low Expressed Emotions
Subsequently, when researchers conducted further studies, they found that patients whose families showed high expressed emotion relapsed more often. Researchers came up with two important concepts: high expressed emotion and low expressed emotion. George Brown formulated the components of expressed emotion. To do so, the researchers secured this information through the patients’ interview responses
- High Expressed Emotions: Families with high expressed emotions indicate that the symptoms are controllable and they also are hostile towards the patients thinking that the patients are not helping themselves. They at times force the patients to pursue their habits and interests. For example: I have asked her, “ To go out, read a book, talk to friends or something like that, to keep the mind distracted”. I guess even this is troublesome for her. I have tried to make her happy or feel joyful. She does not respond to it. I don’t know. The above dialogue reflects the agitation, hostility and a tired attitude towards the patient.
- Low Expressed Emotion: Families with low expressed emotions tend to show patience, calmness and a tendency to leave the patient on their own and not pressure them to quickly adapt to regular functioning. These families are extremely understanding. For example: I don’t force her to be a certain way; it’s better for her to be on her own, and I know that when she wishes to speak, she will speak with me(Barlow et al., 2015).
Components of Expressed Emotions
George Brown formulated the components of expressed emotion. To do so, the researchers obtained this information from the patients’ interview responses. He explained five components of expressed emotion.
1. Hostility
Hostile attitudes of family members involve blaming the individual. The perception of the family is that the individual is in control of the disorder. They think that the patient is not resolving the inner conflict. The attitude starts becoming severe as the family holds the patient accountable for any negative event happening in the family. Most often, the only explanation for any event is the cause of the disorder. This hostile attitude of family members towards the patient makes the patient even more vulnerable to the disorder. The patient starts feeling lonely even among people, and they experience a lack of care and warmth.
2. Over Emotional Involvement
Here, the families are emotionally over-involved with the patient. They are overprotective, self – sacrificing. They either praise or blame the patient way too much. Family members who show high emotional involvement are intrusive. The family holds the perception that the disorder is not under the control of the patient and that the family can interfere and make the disorder somewhat controllable. As a result, patients feel anxious, agitated, or frustrated when families display such emotions. Families with high EE talk more and listen less. When families become emotionally overinvolved, it makes the patient lose their self-esteem, worth and a sense of self because they end up feeling pity for themselves.
3. Critical Comments
The critical attitudes are a combination of hostility and emotional over-involvement. Here, the family members become more open to viewing the disorders in other aspects as well. Negative criticism persists, even if relatives are open-minded.
4. Positive Remarks
Positive remarks consist of appreciation, support and care for the patient. They are expressed by the caregiver in both aspects, such as verbal and nonverbal gestures. One of the best positive remarks is to listen more than talk. Listening with care enables the patient to share what they feel and can express themselves with an open heart. It helps to reduce negative emotions and stress.
5. Warmth
One of the significant factors of Low EE families is warmth. Families express warmth by being empathetic, caring, and offering a gentle smile. As a result, when families show patients warmth, the patients no longer feel scared or afraid of their situation; instead, they gain the ability to cope with it (Mohpatra et al., 2021).”
What do Research Suggest about Expressed Emotions?
In a study conducted by Ng, Fung, and Gao (2020) to understand how both overt and covert behaviours of family members impact patients with schizophrenia. Overt behaviour consists of hostility and criticism, whereas covert behaviour consists of emotional detachment and indifference. They adopted a qualitative semi- structured interview method to collect the data.
1. Participants and Key Findings
There were a total of 22 participants who were diagnosed with schizophrenia. To analyse the interview data, researchers made use of thematic analysis to understand and identify the recurring patterns in the participants’ experiences of family interactions. The findings were consistent with the pre-established dimensions of hostility and emotional over-involvement. They were also able to identify two forms of covert behaviour that impacted patients. They were dissociation ( family members were not engaged with the patients) and apathy(involving indifferent attitudes). Both the overt and covert behaviours impacted the participants. This study emphasised that it is important to look beyond emotional over-involvement and hostility and to understand the dissociation and apathy in the environment.
2. Cross-Cultural Implications: The Chandigarh Study
Jenkins et al. (1991) have also considered the cross-cultural implications of expressed emotion. One of the important considerations is ‘The Chandigarh Study’. This study found that 23% of Indian households were classified as high in EE. A significant component of expressed emotion was hostility. A study conducted by Wang, Cheng, and Yang (2017) aimed to understand how the caregiver’s expressed emotion influenced the burden of caring for an individual with schizophrenia and the patient’s likelihood of schizophrenia.
3. Method, Results and Conclusion
To begin, the study included 64 patients admitted to hospital for the first time in China, along with their primary caregivers. To begin, researchers assessed the caregivers’ expressed emotions using the Chinese version of the Camberwell Family Interview (CFI-CV). The results were again consistent with the previous studies. Moreover, patients whose families showed high expressed emotion experienced rehospitalisation more often than those whose families showed low expressed emotion. Caregivers with higher EE also expressed higher stress burden. Therefore, researchers concluded that negative emotional experiences within the family resulted in poorer outcomes for patients with schizophrenia.
Assessment of Expressed Emotions
Clinicians make use of assessment tools to assess the level of expressed emotions within the family. This helps in treatment planning and quality of treatment outcomes. Several assessment tools are used.
- Camberwell Family Interview (CFI): The Camberwell Family Interview is a semi- structured interview. It is one of the most widely used assessments. It is used with the patient’s immediate family when the patient is not with them. Ratings on five scales are made, i.e., criticism, hostility, emotional over-involvement, warmth and positive remarks. The interview lasts for 2 -3 hours and is intensive. It takes two hours to score each interview record.
- The Five Minute Speech Sample (FMSS): The five-minute speech sample requires the family members to talk about their feelings and thoughts about the patient without any interruption for 5 minutes. If the first speech is negative, it is coded as high EE. FMSS do not assess any dimension of hostility or warmth expressions.
- Level of Expressed Emotion Scale: LEE is a 60-item self-report measure that assesses the emotional environment in the patient’s most important relationships. There are four subscales, which are: intrusiveness, emotional response, attitude towards illness, tolerance and expectation(Mohapatra et al., 2021; Çetinkaya Duman, 2013).
Performance of the assessment
The assessment is usually followed in five steps.
- Initial Preparation: In the first step, the clinician makes the patient aware of the assessment and why it is being done, the importance of it, etc. The patient is asked to complete a questionnaire or talk about the family dynamics. It helps the clinicians to develop a subtle understanding about the family environment of the patient.
- Structured Interview: The second step involves the assessment itself. Clinicians make use of structured interview tools like CRI. Clinicians ask open-ended questions to the patients and family members about relationships and emotional patterns within the family. The ultimate goal is to collect detailed information about the family dynamics.
- Observation and Behavioural Analysis: This is primarily used to understand and monitor family interactions between family members to identify emotional expression. It can take place in clinical settings. This analysis provides additional insights.
- Emotional Health Questionnaires: Patients and family members are both asked to complete various emotional health questionnaires. These questionnaires assess perceived stress, support, and overall well-being. It is quantitative in nature.
- Final Reporting: When all the data is collected, it is organised, compiled and interpreted. This final reporting suggests the level of expressed emotion, enabling the clinician to plan treatment(The Kingsley Clinic, n.d.).
Conclusion
Expressed emotion is the attitude towards the patient of the family members and primary caregivers. George Brown, along with his colleagues, made the first attempt to understand a psychosocial stressor. “Moreover, studies and literature have consistently suggested that patients whose families express high levels of emotion face a higher risk of relapse than those whose families express lower levels. There are five components of expressed emotions.
Moreover, clinicians use several assessment tools to measure expressed emotions among family members. Psychoeducation can help the family to be warm and emotionally supportive with the patient. When clinicians psychoeducate the family or caregivers of the individual, it will help them to understand the disorder and what the patient goes through. Chronic illnesses like schizophrenia need time, patience, trust, warmth and belief in the patient. When people receive adequate emotional support, it can help prevent relapse
References +
- Amaresha, A. C., & Venkatasubramanian, G. (2012). Expressed emotion in schizophrenia: an overview. Indian journal of psychological medicine, 34(1), 12–20
- Mohapatra, S., & Rath, N. (2021). Expressed emotion in psychiatric disorders. Eastern Journal of Psychiatry, 16(1–2), 17–22. https://doi.org/10.5005/EJP-16-1-2-17
- Ng, S.-M., Fung, M. H.-Y., & Gao, S. (2020). High level of expressed emotions in the family of people with schizophrenia: Has a covert abrasive behaviours component been overlooked? Heliyon, 6(11), Article e05441. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e05441
- Jenkins, J. (1992). The meaning of expressed emotion: Theoretical issues raised by cross-cultural research. American journal of psychiatry, 149(1), 9-21. https://escholarship.org/content/qt8953c2xb/qt8953c2xb.pdf
- Wang, X., Chen, Q., & Yang, M. (2017). Effect of caregivers’ expressed emotion on the care burden and rehospitalisation rate of schizophrenia. Patient Preference and Adherence, 11, 1505–1511. https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S143873
- World Health Organisation. (2025, October 6). Schizophrenia. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/schizophrenia
- The Kingsley Clinic. (n.d.). How expressed emotion assessments improve family emotional health. https://thekingsleyclinic.com/resources/how-expressed-emotion-assessments-improve-family-emotional-health/
- Patel, K. R., Cherian, J., Gohil, K., & Atkinson, D. (2014). Schizophrenia: overview and treatment options. P & T: a peer-reviewed journal for formulary management, 39(9), 638–645. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4159061/
- Çetinkaya Duman, Z., Kuşcu, M. K., & Özgün, S. (2013). Comparison between Camberwell Family Interview and Expressed Emotion Scale in Determining Emotions of Caregivers of Schizophrenic Patients. Noropsikiyatri arsivi, 50(4), 301–305. https://doi.org/10.4274/npa.y5832
- Barlow, D. H., & Durand, V. M. (2015). Abnormal psychology: An integrative approach (7th ed.). Cengage Learning.
